While I was
thinking about the borders that I may encounter while on my trip to Belize, I
couldn’t really pinpoint any that meant something to me. I know that sounds
bad, so I decided to look deeper at some of the readings that really pushed the
border issue to give myself a little push in the right direction. The three
readings that I chose, Dalrymple, Matthiessen, and Kapuscinski, to me, show the
most about crossing borders and how those borders can affect the people
crossing them.
In Xandu, written by William Dalrymple, pushed
two borders; ethnic and cultural. Dalrymple, who is from England, decides to
follow the path of Marco Polo into Asia. During his journey he travels through
culturally and ethnically diverse areas that are much different than his own. As
he made his way from Israel to Asia, Dalrymple wrote of the different people
that he came into contact with and the various ethnicities and cultures that he
experienced. For him, as a person just passing through, these
borders seemed more important to understand rather than to cross.
The Cloud Forest, written by Peter Matthiessen, pushed the environmental border that he crossed on his travels in South America. Begin from New York City;
Matthiessen was way out of his element traveling to the jungles of South America.
The Amazon rainforest is a very unique environment, different than any other
place on earth. Matthiessen described it in this way; “[…] the forest is truly beautiful;
it is difficult to conceive of a lovelier place in the world.”
In a previous
post I talked about what I called the “foreigner border” in Ryszard Kapuscinski’s
Travels With Herodotus. Ron seemed interested yet disappointed that I
didn’t take it further. So, I will take it further. To me, the foreigner border
is the hardest and the easiest to cross. I said that this border was more of a
personal problem, feeling like an outsider in an unfamiliar place. When you
feel comfortable in a new environment and not like an outsider, you’ve crossed
the border. That’s the easy part. The hard part comes with the native people
actually accepting you, making you feel welcome, and treating you like one of
them. That’s the hardest part, getting others to view you as their equal in their
country, society, city, or town. Being a foreigner doesn’t mean you have to travel
half way around the world, it means that you are in a place that you are unfamiliar;
a place that people can spot someone different. The best example is a tourist
from Akron going to New York City. They can tell you’re not from around there,
so they might treat you differently. For the sake of my readers I won't take it too much further, but there is another element to this border; time. How long does it take for someone to consider themselves not to be a foriegner, or for natives to accept an outsider as one of thier own?
After taking
some time to look at the borders that others have crossed I think that I will
absorb them as one’s the I see myself crossing in my future travels. Going to Central
America there will definitely be ethnic and cultural borders that I am eager to
cross. Environmental borders can make people uneasy … not knowing what poisonous
thing could bite you in the jungle, yet I am still excited to cross from the concrete
jungle to an actual jungle. The last one, the foreigner border, I think holds
the most weight for me. I throw myself into the places that I travel, immersing
myself into every aspect of a culture. This is probably one reason why I don’t
see myself as a foreigner when I travel, however I think this will be hardest
for me because I won’t be accepted as an equal. I will be a tourist; someone to
eat, drink, and buy products. It saddens me, but as I prepare for my travels it’s
a reality that I have to face.
Megan,
ReplyDeleteNice post bringing a select group of authors into your writing. I liked the example you used for Dalrymple, saying how he thought it was better to pass through borders rather than crossing them. I also thought your two personal borders you mentioned- the environmental and foreigner borders were interesting. I never thought about the environmental aspect, but it is so true. Before we go on vacation we like to look up what type of unique wildlife different states have. As for foreigner borders, I never really give thought to whether I look like a tourist or not except when I am in grocery stores-don’t ask why though, cause I don’t know.
This realization is a powerful one, Megan, and one that I think we all will have to face. Herodotus identified this condition early on, and we can embrace our identity as travelers even as we realize that we will never truly be enmeshed...
ReplyDeleteWow. You definitely took a different approach to your journal than others that I have read. You seem to be very literature oritented in order to turn to books to inspire you for your trip and closely see what borders you will cross. Kapuscinski is a good match for your journey, at least thats how it seems. Although it may be just because i favor him over the other two. His writings seem to match yours, as well as the borders crossed.
ReplyDelete